What to do with old furniture in Columbus: a decision tree

Start here

Answer these in order. The first no sends you down a branch.

1. Is it clean, structurally sound and free of any smell?
2. Would somebody pay for it?
3. Can it get to the curb without you breaking something?
4. Do you have a deadline?

Almost every expensive furniture story in Columbus comes from skipping question four. A sofa that was going to be sold sits in a Westerville garage for two years, and then you pay $126 to remove it anyway, having lost the garage.

Question 1: is it clean and sound?

Be honest, because a charity's door staff will be. Disqualifying: stains, rips, pet damage, a broken frame, and any hint of the smell an item picks up in an unheated basement or garage.

That last one is the Columbus filter. A huge share of the furniture in this city has spent time in a full basement or a detached alley garage, and central Ohio humidity plus a couple of freeze-thaw winters leaves a mark you stop noticing in your own house and everyone else notices immediately.

If no: skip straight to the curb or the haul. Do not spend three weekends listing it.

If yes: continue.

Question 2: would somebody pay for it?

What sells in central Ohio: solid wood, mid-century pieces, recognizable brands, dining sets in late summer, and anything in genuinely good condition during the mid-August campus rush when thousands of people are furnishing houses at once.

What does not sell here, at any price: flat-pack bookcases, sleeper sofas, entertainment centers built for a tube TV, treadmills, and upholstery in a pattern from before 2005. The whole metro is trying to give those away simultaneously.

If it sells: list it in the first week, price it to move, and set a hard deadline. Two weeks, then it goes to the next branch. Furniture that sits on a marketplace for a month is furniture you will pay to remove anyway, a month later.

If it does not sell: continue.

Question 3: will a charity take it?

Columbus is well served here. The Furniture Bank of Central Ohio takes household furniture and places it with families, and there are ReStore locations around the metro that take furniture along with building materials.

Call before you plan around it, and ask three specific things: whether they are currently accepting that category, what their condition standards are, and whether the pickup is curbside or whether they will come inside. Most donation trucks are curbside or ground-floor only, which rules out the second floor of a Victorian Village double and the basement of a Clintonville foursquare.

Calendars fill in August and December. If your timeline is short, this branch will not save you.

If yes: book the donation, and be ready to get it to the curb yourself.

If no: continue.

Question 4: will somebody take it for free?

Timing is everything, and Columbus has one very specific window. The second half of August, when off-campus leases in the University District, Old North and Weinland Park all turn over, a decent free sofa listed on East 14th or Norwich is gone the same day, because somebody three doors down is furnishing a house that afternoon.

Outside that two weeks, the free market in this metro is thin, especially November through February. A free listing in Dublin in January gets read and not answered.

Rules that make it work: photograph it in daylight, say curbside pickup only, give a time window, and give the whole attempt four days. If nobody has come in four days, nobody is coming.

Question 5: can it go at the tree lawn?

Set-out rules for bulky items depend on your address and change from time to time, so check the city's refuse collection page for your street and note the window. In the older neighborhoods with rear service alleys, Italian Village, Olde Towne East, parts of German Village and Merion Village, the alley pad is the set-out point rather than the front.

Two central Ohio cautions. Upholstery left out through a freeze-thaw cycle soaks up melt, gains weight and becomes something nobody will collect or take. And an item put out well outside its window is the thing your neighbors complain about, which in the historic districts is a live and active topic.

The last branch: book it

When the answer to all of the above is no, or when the answer is yes but you have a closing date on Friday, this is the route.

A sofa and a loveseat is $126 + $119 = $245. A dining table with four chairs is $103 + (4 x $45 = $180) = $283. Visit minimum is $75, carry-out from any floor is included, and disposal is in the price.

The two rules that save the most

Deadline every free route. Four days for a giveaway, two weeks for a sale, one phone call for a donation. Then move on. The month you spend waiting costs more than the pickup.

Do it in one visit. The minimum is per visit, not per item. Walk the whole house first, including the basement, the garage and whatever is at the top of the attic stairs, and put it all on one list. A sofa in March and a dresser in July is two minimums and two afternoons off work.

Frequently asked questions